• Diane Hidy

Stop Trying to Teach Creatively

Updated: Sep 20, 2019

Jenny is coming in 15 minutes for her lesson and things didn’t go well last week. She was so distracted that you thought she might quit piano. To be honest, you were kinda hoping she would quit piano. Have you ever felt that way? I certainly have.

You may have been reading a lot about the buzzword “Creativity” in Piano Teaching. Perhaps, you think, you’re not doing well with Jenny because you’re not being creative enough. Doubts rush in. “I need to be more innovative. I need to break out of my rut. I need to be more original. I need a Student Saver piece. A Superhero piece. More chords. Pop Tunes.”

I’d like to propose something else.

What if the problem isn’t that you're not “teaching creatively enough” but that you’ve forgotten to focus on Jenny? What if she isn’t a “problem student,” but simply herself. Not a student in need of a blast of “creativity,” but a student whose behavior is trying to communicate something to you.

Whenever I find myself discouraged with a student like Jenny, I slow myself down. I focus on what I see. I take some time to consider the situation.

  • What is Jenny trying to tell me with her behavior?

  • How can I describe what she’s doing?

  • For example, “Jenny seems distracted.”

If I describe Jenny as distracted, that's helpful but not specific enough. I need to ask myself, “What am I doing that makes her distracted? What were we doing when she started to seem distracted?"

Behavior doesn't happen in a vacuum. Something I've done or asked her to do is making her feel uncomfortable. My job is to figure out what's happened and how to refocus her.

Another of my students, Jason, likes his world complicated. If I ask him a “yes or no” question, his favorite reply is, “Maybe.” This can be challenging. If I’m tired, I can lose my cool.

“Why can’t he just say a simple ‘yes’ when I ask him if he likes something?” I’ll think.

Strangely, that’s exactly the right question to ask.

  • Why can’t he answer a question simply?

  • What is he getting out of the interaction?

My best teaching happens when I stay focused on the messages underneath the words my students are saying. Not, “Jason makes me so angry when he answers a question with ‘maybe.’” But reminding myself to ask, “Why is Jason answering a question that way? What kind of interaction is he looking for? Is he trying to show how quick he is? Is he confused about the real answer? Does he want a higher level conversation? A bigger challenge?”

Here are simple solutions that have worked with Jason:

  • Outweird him. If he says something goofy, I respond with something goofier.

  • Go farther than he did. If he says that the fingering should be, "1, 2, 14, 20," I might respond with, "Hmm...I thought it was 1, 3, 15, 19!" Butting heads with a student like this will backfire. Joining him in his crazy math just might work.

After you’ve established your goal, it's time to think about ways to meet the needs of your students. You may have some quite creative solutions up your sleeve. But talking about Creativity in Teaching as if it were something that happens in a vacuum does us all a disservice. Teaching never happens without a student. A particular student. At a single place. A specific time. Today. Now.

That’s when you meet the student’s needs. Anything else is just a buzz word.

Want to read more? Visit

589 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

© 2019 by Diane Hidy

You'll wonder how you ever taught without this 32-page book. I made these cards for my students to give them plenty of opportunities to practice all the different skills they were acquiring. This series starts with the simplest possible rhythmic patterns on the Landmark notes Middle C, Bass F and Treble G. Each set becomes incrementally more difficult.

Here are a few of the many different ways to use these cards:

  • Encourage students to write in their own fingering. This paves the way for making true fingering choices later on

  • Circle the thirds before starting to read the flashcards. This helps the student focus on the difference between steps and skips.

  • Help your student write in their own staccatos and slurs. Try them out. Talk to them about why they do or don't like them. 

  • Help the student add dynamics and phrase marks.

  • Print these in their entirety and use them as a book.

  • Print them on heavy paper or card stock and cut them into separate cards. Trying sending home a set with a student and ask them to become proficient with each one. At the next lesson, mix them up and play them in random order. It’s a nice combination of preparation and reading.